5 ways to use Substack chat to grow your newsletter community
Join our next office hours, TODAY at 1pm ET (10am PT, 6pm GMT)!
This is a great time to share how your newsletter’s going so far, troubleshoot any early challenges, talk through your plans for the months ahead, or just connect with fellow newsletter creators. Come and join me!
5 ways to use Substack chat to grow your newsletter community
If you only ever use Substack for posts and emails, it’s easy to miss how powerful chat can be. Used well, it’s one of the best ways to turn ‘people who read you’ into ‘people who actually feel like they know you and each other.’
Today I’m sharing five simple, practical ways to use Substack chat to grow and deepen your newsletter community (without requiring you to post all day or become a full‑time moderator).
Host ‘getting to know you’ threads
One of the easiest ways to use chat is simply to ask open questions and let readers talk.
Prompts like “What are you working on this week?”, “Where are you reading from?” or “What’s one small win you’ve had recently?” give people a low‑stakes way to say hello and feel seen.
This does a couple of useful things at once: it helps readers see each other (not just you), it gives you a clearer picture of who is actually in your audience, and it quietly builds a habit of replying.
People who are used to answering quick chat prompts become more likely to comment on posts, share your work, or stick around long term.
Create a free ‘front room’ and a paid ‘back room’
You don’t have to choose between free and paywalled constantly.
One effective structure you can use is:
A free “front room” where anyone can join general, low‑stakes conversations.
A smaller, paywalled “back room” where you host more specific or sensitive discussions.
For example, the front room might be for weekly check‑ins, casual questions and topic brainstorming.
The back room might be where you talk frankly about money, strategy, personal updates or anything you’d rather keep to your core people. Perhaps a space to share your specialist insight.
New readers always have an easy way in, and paying readers have a dedicated space.
Run consistent, recurring threads
Chat threads can work really well when there’s a rhythm.
You don’t have to drop random posts when you remember, pick a couple of recurring threads and stick with them.
Some ideas could include:
A weekly ‘what are you working on?’ check‑in
A Friday ‘extra resources / opportunities’ thread
A monthly Q&A, where people can ask you anything within your niche
The goal is to make the space feel active and engaged.
Add simple, tangible perks for paid readers
Chat is also a simple way to add clear, recurring value for paid subscribers without writing entirely new essays.
You could:
Share a weekly bonus thread (extra opportunities, links, templates, files).
Host paid‑only AMAs on a specific theme (which changes each time): ‘How I wrote a book in three months’, ‘How I successfully pitched the New York Times’, ‘How I plan my gardening calendar’. It could be anything!
Let only paid subscribers start new threads, so they can ask questions and kick off conversations.
The key is to be specific and consistent. ‘Paid readers get extra stuff sometimes’ is too vague. Define what your chat actually involves, then hard sell it.
Make it easy (and safe) for people to talk
Finally, remember that chat should be about conversation as much as anything else.
To keep it interactive, you could:
End chat posts with a clear, easy‑to‑answer question.
Occasionally quote or screenshot a great reply (with permission) to show people the type of participation you enjoy.
Set a few simple house rules (no spam, no harassment, generous good‑faith) and be willing to remove anything that doesn’t fit.
A lightly moderated, friendly chat can become a signal about your whole publication.
Been thinking of growing your newsletter?
Let’s talk about your Substack and explore how I can help you grow.
Book a free 15-minute chat to discuss coaching options, get clarity on your next steps, and see if we’re a good fit. Whether you want to boost growth, engagement, or monetization, this is a no-pressure conversation designed to help you move forward.